The Superior Court of Justice of Madrid (TSJ M) has confirmed the resolution of the Spanish Consulate in Casablanca (Morocco) to deny the visa for the family reunification to a 68-year-old Moroccan who wanted to move to Spain to live with his daughter, who was working. The man alleged that he had been separated from his wife for 15 years, that he had no income of his own and that it was his daughter who sent him the money periodically.
The Justice, for its part, in its ruling STSJ M 9349/2026 (resolution 730/2026, which can be consulted on the website of the General Council of the Judiciary), has considered that it has not been proven that he needs to move to Spain to be cared for by his family. The man had two daughters, one of them with work authorization, receiving a salary and the one who sent him certain amounts to Morocco. To prove it, he showed the documents that proved that money was sent and said that he was alone in Morocco, that he had no one to help him.
The Consulate rejected the request in May 2025, understanding that the situation of vulnerability was not sufficiently proven. For this reason, she decided to file a claim with the courts, but the TSJ of Madrid ruled in favor of the administration because it considered that although she met the age requirement and it had been proven that she was financially dependent on her daughter, she did not demonstrate that she needed to be with her to take care of him.
He had been separated from his wife for 15 years.
The problem began when the man went to request a visa to be able to move to Spain appealing for family reunification. The idea was to reunite with his daughter, who was legally residing in the country and who had a work permit. To prove his financial dependence, he presented documentation that justified that he was receiving money and said that he had no income of his own and that he had not lived with his wife for 15 years, although he was married.
The Consulate responded by alleging that the documentation he had presented did not justify in itself that he needed that help to get ahead and explained that money transfers between family members could simply be due to the need for mutual support and that no situation had arisen that would explain his immediate transfer to Spain.
The applicant indicated that the documentation provided by the Administration was not correct and denied that one of his children was living in Morocco, criticizing the Consulate for not asking for additional documentation explaining that he was not living with his wife.
He did present a marriage certificate, which was in July 2024, where several witnesses confirmed that the couple was living together. But, since they had not separated, the Consulate did not take this situation into account.
A child sending money does not justify family reunification
The TSJ of Madrid has recalled that the immigration rule that applies to this case allows the reunification of parents over 65 years of age but they must meet three requirements. The first of them is to be in charge of the family member who resides in Spain, to be over the established age and to be in a situation that justifies the urgency of the transfer.
The man was born in 1957, so there was no doubt about his age, and regarding economic dependency, the Justice said that it had already been assessed by the Spanish Administration that granted the residence permit for family reunification, so the Consulate could not review it again without having reasons to justify it.
Now, the magistrates had to demonstrate the need for this person to live in Spain with their daughter and, at this point, they indicated that the reunification of parents over 65 years of age must respond to situations of vulnerability aggravated by certain circumstances such as loneliness or a poor state of health.
He closes the neighbor’s drain because it passes through his plot and he reports it because his patio is flooding: the Justice agrees with him because the neighbor had carried out works and he had to install it on his own land

The court denies unemployment to a self-employed person who had been working since 1986 despite demonstrating a drop in his income and spending months without billing anything
But the court considered that the man did not prove these circumstances, pointing out that there was no evidence that he was in “social distress or abandonment of his country of origin” to have to live with his daughter. Furthermore, they took into account that the applicant was still married, although he did not live with his wife and therefore, they considered the absence of support in Morocco as not proven.
