The Superior Court of Justice of Andalusia indicates that the severe disability pension of a man who became quadriplegic after a fall must begin to be counted from the opinion of the medical court, since previously, while he was still undergoing treatment, his consequences could not be assessed. In this way, the man is left without collecting the pension for the almost twelve months that Social Security took to recognize it.
The man worked at Telefónica until November 2013, when “he left the company as a result of the Employment Regulation File (ERE).” After exhausting unemployment, “he signed a Special Agreement with Social Security for contribution purposes until he reached retirement age”, that is, he paid Social Security contributions out of his pocket without working so that his retirement pension would not be affected.
At the end of November 2022, he suffered a fall that caused a spinal cord injury and he became a quadriplegic, so in January 2023 he had to enter the National Hospital for Paraplegics in Toledo and on May 17, “through the hospital’s social worker,” he requested that Social Security recognize his permanent disability.
The medical report did not arrive until April 30, 2024 and spoke of a “63-year-old patient, who after trauma in November 2022 has become a quadriplegic” and who “presents impairment in all work activities with the need for help to carry out basic activities of daily living.” Three days later, the medical court proposed recognizing him as severely disabled, this being the highest degree, which is given to someone who cannot carry out any work activity and also needs another person for the most basic day-to-day tasks, and Social Security granted it with effect from May 3.
The problem is that almost a year passed between one date and another, and the man asked to collect the pension from May 17, 2023, which is when he requested it, but neither Social Security nor the Jaén court agreed with him, so he went to the TSJ.
To understand this, you have to know that a permanent disability that does not come from a medical leave, like this one, begins to count, according to article 13.2 of the Order of January 18, 1996, on “the date of issuance of the opinion-proposal of the disability assessment team”, which is the medical court, even if it was requested much earlier. Only in very specific cases has the Supreme Court allowed it to be brought forward, and this man clung to that, defending that in his case there were “special and concrete circumstances.”
Your pension is collected from the medical opinion
The TSJ of Andalusia has not agreed with him, since, as he explains, “until a pathological scenario is consolidated due to the exhaustion of therapeutic possibilities, it is not feasible to evaluate the extent of the consequences.” That is to say, while a person is still undergoing treatment, one cannot know how they will turn out.
In his case, when he requested the pension he was in rehabilitation and, according to the Chamber, “he was immersed in the set of medical approaches aimed at improving his physical status”, so his situation “was not assessable until a later moment”, which the law coincides with the opinion.
The permanent disability pension would rise by an average of 45 euros per month in 2027 and the maximum of the new ones would reach 3,484 euros per month

Social Security denies him a disability pension for an inheritance of 10 million euros that he never received: they could not prove that it existed and they will have to pay him
In this way and according to the sentence, the man receives severe disability from May 3, 2024 and loses the arrears of the previous eleven and a half months. In this ruling, we must know that the permanent disability of someone who is not on medical leave but continues to contribute, like this man, is charged from the date of the medical court’s ruling and not from the request, so in those cases the time it takes for Social Security to assess the worker is not recovered later.
