Economists question the Sánchez Government's speech on the sustainability of pensions in the middle of the electoral campaign and confirm that the debt rises to 136 billion euros

Economists question the Sánchez Government’s speech on the sustainability of pensions in the middle of the electoral campaign and confirm that the debt rises to 136 billion euros

The electoral campaign is already underway with the main parties offering rallies throughout Spain in which they talk about employment, benefits, immigration and, of course, pensions. A few days ago, the Minister of Inclusion, Social Security and Migration, Elma Saiz, confirmed that the urgent processing of the decree giving the starting signal for the rise in pensions. But, what situation are pensions in Spain? Are they so sustainable as the Sánchez Executive assures?

A new study published by the Foundation for Applied Economic Studies (Fedea) and signed by economist Santiago Calvo, calls into question that good employment data and the recovery of the pension fund are enough to guarantee the financial balance of the system. In the document, it is noted that the Social Security debt with the State already exceeds 136,000 million euros, and spending on benefits is on the rise, above income from contributions.

This analysis confronts the message that the Government is conveying, where they systematically defend the sustainability of the system based on data such as the increase in membership, the pension reform approved in 2023 or the gradual recovery of the Reserve Fund (the pension piggy bank. In Spain, they allege, there are 22.4 million members of Social Security and 2.51 contributors per pensioner. And they hope, regarding the pension fund, that it will reach almost 20,000 million before 2027.

The study points out that an incomplete picture of pension accounts is being given, because they are not going to stop being paid but the cost of maintaining them or the public resources that will need to be allocated to them will increase, as a result, among other things, of the aging of the population.

The pension fund has been recovered, but a significant expense must be faced

As stated before, the Reserve Fund is recovering, after the disaster of 2019 when it was practically empty, with about 2,000 million euros. This growth has been possible thanks to contributions from the MEI (Intergenerational Equity Mechanism), which is an extra contribution paid by companies and workers. This has taken place at the same time as the Social Security debt with the State has increased, which has gone from around 18.5 billion euros in 2021 to 116 billion in 2025, that is, 136 billion current euros.

State transfers have become an important point when it comes to financing the system, and in 2025 they were 3.6% of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) compared to 1.8% in 2019. If these contributions were left out, the basic deficit of the expanded Social Security reached 593.4 billion euros, expressed in constant euros in 2021, while the contributory deficit was 54.3 billion, 3.8% of GDP.

This change is explained by the difference between income and expenses, as can be seen in the statistics for 2007 and 2005 when contributory contributions increased by 29% in real terms, and spending on contributory pensions grew by 82%.

There is more income due to increased employment

The report finds an interesting contrast regarding the labor market, and although high affiliation rates have been highlighted, it is observed that the contributory deficit has risen since 2022, going from 47.7 billion to 54.3 billion euros from 2021 to 2025. The increase in employment has increased income but not enough to offset the increase in spending.

Experts raise questions about the figures given by the Government of 2.1 contributors per pensioner because, when the series published by Social Security are used, it can be seen how in 2026 there were 2.35 contributions per pensioner and 2.13 per contributory pension.

The spending rule is met but there could be problems in the future

The Independent Authority for Fiscal Responsibility (AIReF) has confirmed that in Spain the pension spending rule that came into effect with the 2023 reform is being complied with. In the data presented in the month of May (2026) this independent body confirmed that the average spending on pensions, if income measures were discounted, would be between 13% of GDP between 2022 and 2050 under the limit of 13.3%.

It must be considered that there is an aging of the population, as pointed out by the National Institute of Statistics (INE) in data collected by this report. Spain will go from having 3.15 people between 16 and 64 years old for every person over that age in 2025 to having just 1.93 in 2050, when the ‘baby boomers’ retire.

Social Security retirement simulator: how to calculate pension with or without digital ID

Professional drivers announce a strike at Christmas to demand their right to early retirement without cuts

For this reason, as the author points out, structural reforms can be addressed, including a system of notional accounts that relates pensions to contributions made during working life and complementary savings for retirement. The country, therefore, is not facing a bankruptcy of the pension system as some parties have stated during this electoral campaign, but rather the State can guarantee that pensions will be paid. It warns, however, that maintaining the current model will pose a series of imbalances that will require more and more public money for pensions, which could affect other policies such as access to housing, education or infrastructure.