A neighbor installs a closet in her patio to store junk and Justice says she has to remove it because it was anchored to common elements and the statutes prohibited it

A neighbor installs a closet in her patio to store junk and Justice says she has to remove it because it was anchored to common elements and the statutes prohibited it

The Provincial Court of Granada has ruled in favor of a community of neighbors who demanded that a homeowner remove a closet that she had installed in the patio of her home to store junk. Although the woman had exclusive use of that space, the patio was a common element of the building and she had secured the closet with screws to the walls. without community authorization.

According to the ruling of July 14, 2026, the owner had installed a closed and covered storage closet, for which she had partially cut several gutters from the patio walls. I had also placed a profile for a awning anchored to the façade. Faced with this situation, the community approved by majority to demand that he remove the facilities, since the statutes prohibited carrying out works or placing enclosures on the terraces.

The woman decided to sue the community to annul that agreement and the Court of First Instance of Granada initially agreed with her, considering that the closet could not be classified as an enclosure and that the modifications were not serious. However, the Provincial Court revoked this decision when it understood that the owner had altered common elements without permission and against the provisions of the statutes.

Although the patio was for private use, the common elements could not be modified without permission.

Article 7.1 of the Horizontal Property Law, which can be consulted in the BOEestablishes that owners cannot make alterations to the common elements of the building. Furthermore, article 9.1 requires respect for these elements, even if they are intended for the exclusive use of one of the neighbors.

In this case, the community statutes expressly established that the uncovered terraces were common elements, although Its use corresponds to the owners of the homes.. They also prohibited carrying out works of any kind, covering the terraces or installing enclosures, as well as modifying the façade of the building.

The Court considered that the owner had failed to comply with these regulations by installing a closed and covered closet, fixing it with screws to the community walls and cutting part of the flashing. For this reason, he explained that having the exclusive use of a patio does not allow it to be freely modified, since it continues to form part of the common elements of the building.

The fact that other neighbors had enclosures did not justify installing the closet without authorization

The homeowner also alleged that other neighbors had installed even larger fences in their yards without asking permission, and that the community had not required them to remove them. However, the Court rejected this argument because it had not been proven that the community had authorized or consented to these facilities.

Furthermore, the ruling indicates that, at a meeting held in 2015, the woman had already communicated her intention to place a booth on the terrace. Then, the administration asked him to submit an application with photographs, measurements and a description to study his proposal. Despite this, he ended up carrying out the installations without having authorization.

In this sense, the Court recalls that article 17.7 of the Horizontal Property Law allows agreements that do not require a special majority to be adopted by majority. The unanimity of the owners was not necessary, as the woman defended, because the community was not modifying the statutes, but demanding that they be fulfilled.

A woman hangs two t-shirts in the yard of her house and a neighbor reports her: four years later she receives a fine of 213 euros

A community of neighbors prohibits a couple from taking their 4-kilo dog in the elevator and Justice agrees with them: they will have to use the stairs

For all this, the Justice ruled in favor of the community and considered valid the agreement that required removing the closet and the other installed elements, although against the sentence (SAP GR 1347/2026) it was possible to file an appeal.