The SEPE removes the unemployment benefit from a father of three daughters and asks him to return 8,289.83 euros for the profit he had declared to the Treasury, but the court annuls it

The SEPE removes the unemployment benefit from a father of three daughters and asks him to return 8,289.83 euros for the profit he had declared to the Treasury, but the court annuls it

The SEPE withdrew the unemployment benefit from a father of three daughters and requested that he return the 8,289.83 euros collected for not notifying a profit of 14,528.73 euros. Now, the Superior Court of Justice of Andalusia has annulled this decision, since that money appeared in his Income Tax return and he himself had already paid it in full and with interest.

The man had the subsidy recognized by the State Public Employment Service since May 2017, but in February 2018 he obtained a capital gain of 14,528.73 euros (the sentence does not detail what this increase is due to) which he included in his Income tax return to the Treasury of that year.

The SEPE distributed that profit among the twelve months of the year, which amounted to 1,210.72 euros per month, being above the limit of 75% of the minimum interprofessional salary for that year (551.92 euros in 2018) and which sets the article 275 of the General Law of Social Security. THE SEPE informed him that in October 2019 they were going to withdraw his aid for not having notified him and in November they claimed everything unduly collected from February 2018 to September 2019 (a total of 8,289.83 euros).

The man asked to pay the debt in installments, but when he collected another SEPE benefit again, between 2021 and 2022, the organization collected what it owed him from those payments, so in the end he ended up paying the 8,289.83 euros plus interest. Not being satisfied with this decision, he decided to take his case to court and the Seville court annulled the claim, so the SEPE wanted to appeal it to the TSJ.

The SEPE did not refute the lack of guilt

To remove the aid, the SEPE applied article 25 of the Law on Infractions and Sanctions in the Social Order (can be consulted at this link), which punishes not communicating the changes that result in losing the right to the benefit. The court understands that, to punish, fault is necessary, and that there was none here, since, as the TSJ explains, “the imputation of fault cannot derive from an alleged desire to conceal the income received, given that it appears in the tax return.”

According to the Court, the man exceeded the limit and “did not meet the first requirement of lack of personal income.” The SEPE defended in its appeal that it exceeded that limit and that it did not communicate it, but it did not refute the lack of fault. The Court explains that it cannot construct that argument on its own, so it confirms the Seville ruling and nullifies the claim for the 8,289.83 euros, although it does not say anything about what happens to the money that the man has already paid.

From November 1, 2024, the SEPE sanctions the first time you are not notified of such a change with three months without payment, the second with six and only the third with the withdrawal, if no more than a year passes between them. Before, the withdrawal was direct, and apart from the punishment, the law requires returning what was overpaid.

Starting in 2027, the SEPE will grant the subsidy for those over 52 years of age to workers with incomes of less than 964 euros gross per month, if the increase in the minimum wage is approved.

The SEPE allows the subsidy to be collected for those over 52 years of age even if a pension plan is rescued if the earnings do not exceed 75% of the SMI

What the man did not get is for the SEPE to pay the costs (trial expenses) for having appealed. In the sentence (available at this link from the Judiciary), the Court explains that the organization limited itself to defending its position and that “it is not observed at all that the managing entity can be imputed either recklessness or bad faith.”