The company may have to 'pay' you part of the income tax return: “Very few people know this”

The company may have to ‘pay’ you part of the income tax return: “Very few people know this”

Many workers are unaware that the personal income tax withholdings that appear on their payslips are not always correct and that a company error can have consequences when submitting the Income Tax return. Specifically, it can cause the declaration to come out ‘to pay’, having to pay the Tax Agency everything that was not contributed on the day, month by month.

In this scenario, there is a less known possibility, and that is that the worker does not have to assume the consequences of that error when the responsibility lies exclusively with the company. “It is possible that the company will have to pay what you get in your income tax return. Very few people know this, it is no joke and it is included in the law,” labor lawyer Juan Manuel Lorente explained in a video.

The standard referred to is Law 35/2006 on Personal Income Tax, which in its article 99 establishes that “when the withholding had not been made or had been for an amount less than the amount due, for reasons attributable exclusively to the withholder or obliged to pay on account, the recipient will deduct from the fee the amount that should have been withheld.”

This means that, if a company has withheld less personal income tax than was due due to an error exclusively on its part, the worker does not have to assume that difference in his or her income tax return.

“This is the necessary requirement for your tax return to be paid”

In order to benefit from this possibility, it is necessary that the error be solely attributable to the company and not be due, for example, to the worker providing incorrect information about his or her personal or family situation.

“If the company practices a withholding lower than what is required by law, you will have to pay your income tax return. But you should not have to assume this cost, it should be assumed by your company. They should have practiced the correct withholding in accordance with the provisions of the law and your circumstances. And this is the necessary requirement for your tax return to be paid,” tax advisor Julia Coronel clarifies in the same video.

The Central Economic-Administrative Court (TEAC), in its resolution of April 26, 2022, collected by Iberley, established three requirements so that the taxpayer can deduct the amounts that should have been withheld:

  • Declare all income: the worker must include in his Income Tax return all the income received subject to withholding and exercise the right to deduct the amounts that should have been withheld.
  • That the error belongs exclusively to the company: the incorrect withholding must be the responsibility of the person who was obliged to practice it, without the worker having contributed to the error.
  • That the Treasury’s right to claim has not expired: the Tax Agency must retain the possibility of demanding from the company the withholdings that it should have made.

The first two requirements constitute binding doctrine of the TEAC. On the other hand, the third, related to prescription, is a relevant criterion that has not yet been reiterated and that does not constitute binding doctrine for the purposes of article 239 of the General Tax Law.

The Treasury confirms that selling your habitual home to buy another does not automatically free you from paying personal income tax if you do not complete this procedure

The Treasury confirms that self-employed people who work from home can deduct the IBI, the community of neighbors and the interest on the mortgage

Therefore, when these conditions are met, the worker can avoid assuming in his declaration the consequences of an error committed exclusively by the company. Of course, this does not mean that the company has to pay the income directly, but rather that the taxpayer can deduct the withholdings that legally should have been applied.