Social Security denies the extension of orphanhood to a 25-year-old girl who is preparing for the exams for judge and justice recognizes it because taking the exam is also studying

Social Security denies the extension of orphanhood to a 25-year-old girl who is preparing for the exams for judge and justice recognizes it because taking the exam is also studying

The Superior Court of Justice of Andalusia agrees with a young woman from Almería to be able to continue collecting the orphan’s pension after turning 25 as she continues to prepare for the judicial and fiscal career exams. Social Security pointed out that studying is not the same as taking the exam, but for justice it is the same.

This young woman began to collect the orphan’s pension in February 2024, after being granted it by the National Social Security Institute (INSS) that same month, but in December of that same year the organization notified her that it would stop paying it to her when she turned 25 (she turned 25 on January 17, 2025), “unless she continued studying,” as the ruling explains (you can read it in the Judiciary).

He did so and four days before turning 25, he asked Social Security for an extension, to which he received no response. That’s why she complained, but the INSS still rejected her, so she had to go to court and prove that she was “preparing competitive exams for access to the judicial and fiscal career during the 2024-2025 academic year.” The Social Court of Almería agreed with him, and the INSS, not agreeing, appealed to the TSJ.

The General Law of Social Security speaks of “pursuing studies”, without requiring that they be regulated

He article 224 of the General Law of Social Security points out that if the orphan “was studying and turned twenty-five during the course of the school year,” the pension is maintained “until the first day of the month immediately following the beginning of the month following the academic year.” Added to this is that, between the ages of 21 and 25, the orphan’s pension is only collected if the orphan does not work or if what he or she earns from that job per year does not reach the minimum interprofessional wage.

Social Security understands that these studies must be “regulated and organized”, but not what this young woman was doing, understanding that they are “informal and self-organizing” in nature. In addition, he pointed out that the oppositions have neither courses nor an “estimated” duration, and can even be extended for years, when the purpose of the extension is to extend the pension for a few months, until the end of the academic year.

The Superior Court of Justice of Andalusia does not see it that way, because as other courts in Murcia or the Valencian Community point out, preparing for oppositions is studying. According to the Valencian ruling they cite, the expression “pursuing studies”, “due to its breadth, allows various forms of studies to be included within such phrase”, including those that prepare for competitive examinations. They also add that the norm responds to the “notorious social phenomenon of the prolongation of the academic or professional training of young people” and their “prolonged stay” in the care of the family.

30% of retirees do not make ends meet but give money to their children to pay rent, groceries or studies

In 2027, Social Security will suspend the non-contributory retirement or disability pension for those who do not submit the annual income declaration in the first quarter and do not heed the notice

Now, what the ruling does not say or clarify is until when the extension of the orphan’s pension can be extended, since some exams can be passed in one year or several. According to the TSJ it is difficult, but that is no reason to deny it. Thus, the court agrees with the young woman to continue studying her competitive examinations while maintaining the collection of the orphan’s pension until the next course with the amount that corresponds to her.