Social Security denies permanent disability to a hairdresser with asthma who is prohibited from using dyes and hair sprays, after a respiratory test came back normal, and the court ends up recognizing her five years later

Social Security denies permanent disability to a hairdresser with asthma who is prohibited from using dyes and hair sprays, after a respiratory test came back normal, and the court ends up recognizing her five years later

The Superior Court of Justice of Andalusia understands that a hairdresser with severe asthma that worsens with dyes and hair sprays cannot continue working in a hair salon, even if her spirometry (one of the tests that measure breathing) comes out normal. In this way, it recognizes the total permanent disability that Social Security denied him in 2021, with a pension of 55% of a regulatory base of 739.21 euros.

According to the ruling (available in the Judiciary and against which an appeal can be made to the Supreme Court), the woman, born in 1977, worked as a self-employed hairdresser until the end of 2019, when she had to take medical leave due to temporary disability and finally had to close the business. In April of that year, he had already gone to the pulmonologist, and the report states that the reason was “intolerance to hairdressing products, an asthma attack and a severe cough with itching and severe discomfort.” Two months later, the allergist noted that “it gets worse with work and hairspray and cleaning products” and that “he goes to the emergency room at least 3 times every month.”

Due to this situation, he requested permanent disability from Social Security, but it was denied, since, according to the medical court, he had “allergic ASTHMA (grasses)”, that is, to pollen, with “Spirometry in normal ranges”. That is why his conclusion was that “he does not meet IP criteria” (permanent disability), so at most he would need a leave of absence when he had a crisis.

To understand it, you must know that total permanent disability is, according to article 194 of the General Social Security Law, that given to someone who can no longer continue in their usual profession, even if they can dedicate themselves to another, and that with it 55% of the regulatory base is collected (the amount on which the pension is calculated). The ruling itself summarizes it by saying that “the ailments themselves do not matter as much as the effective functional limitations generated by them,” and that these must be put “in connection with the profession or trade of the interested party.”

The woman went to court and was not lucky the first time either, since a court in Granada rejected her claim in July 2025. Previously, another court had ruled out that her sick leave due to asthma had a work-related origin, and she waived her claim in court, so the case has been resolved as a common illness.

Without dyes or lacquers, no hairdressing is possible

Now, the TSJ of Andalusia has agreed with him, and has done so after adding to the facts the reports of public health specialists, which the court had not collected. In these reports the same thing is repeated year after year, that he has “severe persistent asthma with an important professional component” and that “he must avoid environments with chemicals, vapors, toxins, hair dyes and hairsprays.”

What’s more, the Chamber focuses on a test that was carried out at the University of Navarra Clinic, where the amount of air that could be expelled in one second dropped by 21% “after exposure and manipulation of the mixture of dyes and H2O2” (peroxide). With all this, he understands that these products “make it advisable for him to abandon his professional activity.”

The court has left out other ailments that the woman alleged, since they are still pending diagnosis, and has recognized her total permanent disability “with the right to a monthly lifetime pension of 55% of her regulatory base of 739.21 euros.” 55% of that base is about 407 euros, but the law does not allow this pension, when it comes from a common illness, to go below the minimum, which in 2026 is 684.30 euros per month in 14 payments (as regulated by article 196 of the same law).

Social Security denies him a disability pension for an inheritance of 10 million euros that he never received: they could not prove that it existed and they will have to pay him

A supermarket cashier with multiple sclerosis achieves a lifetime pension based on 1,158.95 euros after almost eight years without working and being denied it by Social Security

Not all hairdressers achieve it, since, as NoticiasTrabajo reported in October, the justice system approved that Social Security denied it to another hairdresser in her 60s with persistent covid and wear and tear on her spine, understanding that she could continue working standing up.